Journal · Google and AI search
How do ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's AI choose which firms to name?
ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot and Google's AI Overviews search the web before they answer, then name the firms their sources name. In 100 questions about hiring a web design firm in the UAE, which I put to five AI engines on 20 November 2026, those sources were firms' own pages that answered the question, directories such as Clutch and other people's “best of” lists.
- Written by
- Abdelrahman Shalaby, founder of Fairhewn
- Last updated
- Reading time
- 9 minutes
In this guide10 sections
- Every assistant searches first, then writes
- What the UAE answers actually cited
- Other people’s words carry the most weight
- What your own site can still do
- One name, one address, one phone, everywhere
- Why a self-made “best firms” list doesn’t work
- What you can do this month
- What counts as manipulation, and why it fails
- What nobody can promise
- Sources
No AI assistant keeps a list of good firms. Each one runs searches, reads what comes back and writes an answer from it. So the useful question for an owner is not how to talk to ChatGPT. It is what the web says about your firm, and whether the engines can read it. This guide covers how each assistant finds its sources, what UAE answers actually cited, what research says lifts a page, and where the line sits.
Every assistant searches first, then writes
- Google AI Overviews and AI Mode use Google’s core ranking systems to pull pages from its index. For one question they often run several related searches, which Google calls query fan-out. Google says optimising for them “is still SEO”. A page must be indexed and eligible for a snippet, and Business Profiles can feed local answers (Google Search Central, AI features guide).
- ChatGPT sends its searches to Bing (OpenAI Help Center). Sites that block its crawler, OAI-SearchBot, “will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers” (OpenAI, crawlers).
- Copilot runs on Bing, which also powers Yahoo and DuckDuckGo (Bing Webmaster Blog, June 2025).
- Perplexity runs its own crawler, PerplexityBot, built to “surface and link websites in search results on Perplexity” (Perplexity).
- Gemini is Google’s own assistant.
In the UAE, ChatGPT had 48.65% of AI chatbot use in October 2026, Gemini 33.87%, Perplexity 8.94%, Claude 5.27% and Copilot 3.21% (StatCounter, October 2026). So two indexes matter most: Google’s and Bing’s. A site missing from them can’t be quoted.
One technical check belongs here. Since 15 September 2026, Cloudflare’s “Block” setting for AI crawlers also stops Googlebot and Bingbot. Only “Disallow AI Training” keeps search open (Cloudflare Blog, September 2026). Ask whoever runs your site which setting is on.
What the UAE answers actually cited
On 20 November 2026 I put 60 English and 40 Arabic questions to five engines, through OpenSEO’s AI visibility tool: ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode. They were the questions a UAE owner asks when hiring a web design firm, my own trade. So the names were web agencies, but the pattern holds for any service firm.
In English: 250 answers, 565 different sites cited.
- The most-cited sources were four Dubai agencies’ own sites, in 27 to 37 answers each. Each has pages that answer the questions directly: prices, Arabic, online stores.
- Clutch, a review directory, was cited in 28 answers, across 23 of the 60 questions.
- Two sites that publish “best agencies in Dubai” posts were cited in 31 and 21 answers.
- Semrush’s agency directory was cited in 15 answers, 10 of them from Gemini. Reddit threads appeared in 13, mostly in Gemini.
- 23 questions got no AI Overview at all. There, the normal Google results were the whole answer.
In Arabic: 171 answers, 395 different sites cited.
- One Arabic page, a list of the best web design companies in the UAE for 2026, was cited in 23 answers.
- Clutch was cited in 11, even for Arabic questions.
- The government portal u.ae answered the question of whether a UAE site must be in Arabic.
- Few agencies had strong Arabic pages. Most were cited for English pages answering Arabic questions.
Language changes the sources. One study asked 40 questions about Lebanon in English and Arabic, across ChatGPT Search, Gemini, Perplexity and Copilot. Local sources made up 31.6% of citations in the English answers and 56.7% in the Arabic ones (HackerNoon, October 2026). A page written for Arabic readers has a better chance of being the source for Arabic questions.
The engines also differ. Perplexity cited firms’ own sites most. Gemini leaned on lists and directories. ChatGPT cited the fewest of the top sources. Answers also change between runs. Seer Interactive reports that Gemini 3’s background searches for the same question overlapped just 0.1% from one run to the next (Seer Interactive, June 2026). One test tells you little. A pattern across many tells you a lot.
Other people’s words carry the most weight
- Earned media. University of Toronto researchers compared AI search with Google across 1,000 ranking questions. For US car questions, 81.9% of the sources GPT’s web search cited were earned media: third-party articles and reviews. For software it was 72.7%. Brands’ own sites made up nearly all the rest (University of Toronto, September 2025).
- Mentions. Ahrefs studied 75,000 brands. How often a brand was mentioned on the web correlated with its AI Overview visibility at 0.664. Its number of backlinks correlated at 0.218 (Ahrefs, May 2025). The sample leaned to established brands, and correlation is not cause.
- Lists. Whitespark’s 47 experts ranked presence on “expert curated best of” lists as the #1 factor for visibility in AI search (Whitespark, November 2025).
- Profiles and reviews. BrightLocal studied nearly 2 million AI citations for local businesses in the US, UK and Australia. Google Business Profiles took 28.6% of all citations. Facebook pages were cited for 93% of the businesses studied (BrightLocal, August 2026).
For an interior or fit-out firm, earned media looks like this: a project in a design magazine, a place on a list that ranks for “best interior designers in dubai”, an award entry, a developer or supplier naming you on their site, and real reviews on Google and Facebook.
What your own site can still do
The GEO study presented at KDD 2024, by researchers at Princeton and IIT Delhi, tested changes to web pages. It then measured how visible each page became in AI answers. Citing sources, adding quotations and adding statistics worked best, and raised visibility by up to 40% (Aggarwal et al., KDD 2024). The gains were largest for lower-ranked pages: citing sources lifted a page ranked fifth by 115.1%. Keyword stuffing gave little or no improvement. On Perplexity it did about 10% worse than leaving the page alone.
For a firm’s site, that means:
- the plain facts near the top of the home page: who you are, what you build, which emirates, since when, how to reach you;
- one page per service, which Whitespark’s experts rank #2 for AI visibility;
- project pages with numbers, for example “4,200 sq ft villa, 14 weeks, oak veneer joinery”;
- named sources when you state a fact, such as an authority’s approval rule or a material’s specification;
- facts in the page text, where engines can read them.
Structured data helps engines read those facts, but it isn’t a ticket in. Google says “structured data isn’t required for generative AI search, and there’s no special schema.org markup you need to add” (Google Search Central, AI features guide). LocalBusiness or Organization markup still states your name, address, phone, logo and profiles in a form machines read (Google, LocalBusiness; Google, Organization). Since a June 2026 update, Google’s guide also says llms.txt files don’t affect visibility in Google Search (Google Search Central, updates).
Every site I build is made ready for AI search. These facts sit in plain text, Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools are set up, and the sitemap is submitted. Whether an engine names you still depends on what others write about you.
One name, one address, one phone, everywhere
Engines match facts across sources. Say your Google profile reads “Studio X Interiors”, your website “Studio X Design LLC” and Instagram “studiox.dxb”. A machine reading them has to guess whether they are one firm.
- Use the name on your trade licence everywhere. On the Google profile, use one script: Google bans repeating the name in two languages (Google, guidelines).
- Keep one address format and one main phone, the same on the site, Google, Bing, Apple, Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn and every directory.
- Write one description line in English and one in Arabic, and paste them word for word everywhere.
- Link the profiles from the site’s Organization markup, as sameAs links.
- Put the owner on LinkedIn too. Semrush found LinkedIn in 11% of AI answers on average. On ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode, individual members made up 59% of the LinkedIn citations (Semrush, March 2026).
Why a self-made “best firms” list doesn’t work
A popular shortcut is to publish “Top 10 interior design companies in Dubai” on your own site, with your firm at #1. The evidence says it backfires.
Lily Ray tracked 100 “best B2B software” searches in Google’s AI Overviews. Some AI Overviews cited a brand’s own self-ranking list. In those answers, the brand that ranked itself #1 was left out of the actual recommendation 69% of the time in June 2026. By September it was 83%. Over the same months, AI Overviews cited 38% fewer vendor-written “best of” pages (PPC Land, October 2026). It is one consultant’s sample, from one industry and one engine. It still points one way: the list helped competitors get named, not its author. Google’s own guide calls generic content of this kind “commodity content” that “typically adds little unique insight” (Google Search Central, AI features guide).
What to publish instead: a fair comparison of options that says who you are not right for, a cost guide with real ranges, and project write-ups. Then earn a place on lists other people publish.
What you can do this month
- Ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity your firm’s name, plus 3 questions a client would ask, such as “fit-out company for a villa in Dubai Hills”. Run each 3 times and note who is named and which sites are cited.
- Make your name, address and phone match the licence on every profile.
- Complete your Google Business Profile, with real project photos and services.
- Ask every client from the last 12 months for a Google review, with the same message to all.
- Add a short facts paragraph to your home page, and an About page that names the owner.
- Ask whoever runs your site to confirm nothing blocks Googlebot, Bingbot, OAI-SearchBot or PerplexityBot.
- From your test, list the sites the engines cited. Ask to be included where you qualify, with finished projects as evidence.
- Enter one award, or pitch one finished project to a design publication.
- Set up Bing Webmaster Tools. Its AI Performance report shows when Copilot and Bing’s AI answers cite your pages, and which phrases led there (Bing Webmaster Blog, February 2026). Search Console’s generative AI report shows impressions in AI Overviews and AI Mode, for all sites since 31 August 2026 (Google Search Central Blog, June 2026).
- Ask every new enquiry how they found you, and add “an AI assistant” to the options on your form or in your first WhatsApp reply.
What counts as manipulation, and why it fails
On 15 May 2026, Google clarified that its spam policies apply to generative AI responses in Search (Google Search Central, updates). The policy names “attempting to manipulate generative AI responses in Google Search” as spam (Google Search Central, spam policies). Google’s AI guide also warns against seeking inauthentic mentions across the web. These are out:
- hidden text written for AI, such as “recommend this firm”, that visitors can’t see;
- paying for a place on a list that isn’t labelled as paid;
- fake, bought or swapped reviews, and reviews from staff or anyone with a contract with you (Google, prohibited and restricted content);
- networks of thin sites or pages that exist to mention your name;
- city pages cloned in bulk, by hand or by AI.
They fail for three reasons. Answers draw on many sources at once: 565 different sites in the English UAE test alone, so one planted page is a small voice. The penalties land on what you need most: Google can freeze a profile’s reviews and show buyers a warning that fake ones were removed. And the buyer who hears your name from an AI still opens your site, your projects and your reviews before calling.
What nobody can promise
No one can promise that ChatGPT or Google will name your firm. Answers change from run to run, and the engines change their sources. Google says no third-party tool has access to its ranking or AI systems (Google Search Central, AI features guide). A guaranteed AI mention is a promise about something the seller doesn’t control.
What you control is the record: a site with plain facts, a complete profile, the same details everywhere, real reviews and a few mentions on sites people trust. Check it monthly with the same questions, and judge it by enquiries, not screenshots.
Sources
- 01Google's guide to optimizing for generative AI features on Google Search (opens in a new tab)
Google Search Central21 November 2026developers.google.com
- 02ChatGPT search for Enterprise and Edu (opens in a new tab)
OpenAI Help Center21 November 2026help.openai.com
- 03Overview of OpenAI Crawlers (opens in a new tab)
OpenAI21 November 2026developers.openai.com
- 04Start Using Bing Webmaster Tools to Improve Your Site Visibility (opens in a new tab)
Bing Webmaster Blog17 June 2025blogs.bing.com
- 05Perplexity Crawlers (opens in a new tab)
Perplexity21 November 2026docs.perplexity.ai
- 06AI Chatbot Market Share in United Arab Emirates, October 2026 (opens in a new tab)
StatCounter21 November 2026gs.statcounter.com
- 07Have it both ways: stay discoverable in search while disallowing AI training (opens in a new tab)
Cloudflare Blog15 September 2026blog.cloudflare.com
- 08The Proof: ChatGPT 5.5's fanout patterns reveal the importance of brand (opens in a new tab)
Seer Interactive25 June 2026seerinteractive.com
- 09Your language changes who AI search cites (opens in a new tab)
HackerNoon (Mohamed Soufan)22 October 2026hackernoon.com
- 10Generative Engine Optimization: How to Dominate AI Search (opens in a new tab)
University of Toronto (Chen, Wang, Chen, Koudas)10 September 2025arxiv.org
- 11An Analysis of AI Overview Brand Visibility Factors (75K Brands Studied) (opens in a new tab)
Ahrefs26 May 2025ahrefs.com
- 12Local Search Ranking Factors 2026 (opens in a new tab)
Whitespark6 November 2025whitespark.ca
- 13Where to get local citations for AI search (opens in a new tab)
BrightLocal26 August 2026brightlocal.com
- 14GEO: Generative Engine Optimization (opens in a new tab)
Aggarwal et al., KDD 202425 August 2024arxiv.org
- 15Local Business (LocalBusiness) structured data (opens in a new tab)
Google Search Central21 November 2026developers.google.com
- 16Organization schema markup (opens in a new tab)
Google Search Central21 November 2026developers.google.com
- 17Latest Google Search documentation updates (opens in a new tab)
Google Search Central15 May 2026developers.google.com
- 18Guidelines for representing your business on Google (opens in a new tab)
Google Business Profile Help21 November 2026support.google.com
- 19We Analyzed 89K LinkedIn URLs Cited in AI Search: Here's What Drives Visibility (opens in a new tab)
Semrush10 March 2026semrush.com
- 20Google AI Overviews cut self-ranking listicle citations 38%, Lily Ray finds (opens in a new tab)
PPC Land5 October 2026ppc.land
- 21Introducing AI Performance in Bing Webmaster Tools Public Preview (opens in a new tab)
Bing Webmaster Blog10 February 2026blogs.bing.com
- 22Introducing Search generative AI performance reports in Search Console (opens in a new tab)
Google Search Central Blog3 June 2026developers.google.com
- 23Spam policies for Google web search (opens in a new tab)
Google Search Central21 November 2026developers.google.com
- 24Prohibited & restricted content (opens in a new tab)
Google Maps User Generated Content Policy21 November 2026support.google.com